Navigate: main >> reviews
F U L L . R E V I E W S



Uli Jon Roth
Under a Dark Sky

Company: SPV
Release: 2008
Genre: Hard rock, traditional
Reviewer: Vinaya

  • Quite a noble venture, yet fatiguing



  • German guitar innovator Uli Jon Roth has been one of my favorite guitarists since I first discovered his work via the Scorpions' 1975 In Trance album (two decades after the fact) in high school. Like fellow Scorpions alumnus Michael Schenker and Irish virtuoso Gary Moore, Roth was one of those early metal guitar heroes who never got the respect he was due, particularly in the States, where the public seemed to credit the shred revolution of the 1980's almost entirely to Eddie Van Halen, the late Randy Rhoads and to a lesser degree, Yngwie Malmsteen.

    And while it was primarily his work with the Scorpions and his own Electric Sun project that always interested me, I was pleased to discover a few years ago that Roth was still active, and I have since picked up and enjoyed much of his recent work. Every once in awhile, however, Roth's work seems to take a good thing just a hair too far, and as much as I love his playing all around, I have to say that Under a Dark Sky is not destined to draw the type of immediate appreciation I (and likely many other listeners) felt upon hearing Roth classics like the Scorpions' "Dark Lady" and Electric Sun's "Cast away your Chains" for the first time.

    With eight vocalists (plus the Sky Choir), the Sky Orchestra and twelve-part closing number in "Tanz In Die Dammerung", even a casual glance at the album's credits and track listing tells you that this is not an album for those who cannot take anything much more ambitious than a straightforward three-minute pop song, to say the least. And while I cannot say with certainty that I know all of the album's lyrics inside out (since my promo copy lacks a lyric sheet), I get the impression that the album is tied together by a fairly heavy lyrical theme as well. The dramatic three-part "Land of Dawn" (one of the album's more accessible tracks) and other songs seem to focus on the emotional coarsening and desensitizing of people through technology, at the expense of the earth and all its creatures.

    Performances by all involved are dramatic and technically flawless, especially on the part of Roth and vocalist Mark Boals (ex-Yngwie Malmsteen, Royal Hunt). The musical composition and arrangements are also quite ambitious throughout, to the point where one almost gets the sense that even Boals is fairly challenged by the album's content.

    On one level, this is quite a noble venture, given the sheer quantity, quality and depth of material on offer, and Roth's clear effort to produce a decidedly non-disposable piece of art. However, the heavy drama, elaborate composition (including some tricky vocal melodies) and extreme seriousness of it all can seem like a bit much after a while, and I suspect that some listeners will find the intense and occasionally shrill nature of it somewhat fatiguing. Given Roth's stated belief in the need for greater meaning in music and art in general, however, something tells me that giving this album some time to really sink in will prove rewarding for those brave enough- or crazy enough- to take the plunge.



    About this Writer:
    Vinaya Saksena // Vinaya is either a writer who dabbles in guitar playing, or a guitar player who dabbles in writing. A Maximum Metal staffer since 2004, he has also served as a reporter for several newspapers in Rhode Island and Massachusetts. Although his obsession with music is such that it does not allow time for much else by way of hobbies, he also enjoys traveling, trivia, photography, British comedy and the occasional A-Team re-run.

    Maximum Metal Rating Legend - Click for Full Details
    5 Excellent - Buy it and say a prayer to the metal gods that you were tuned on to this masterpiece. A classic.
    4-4.5 Great - Almost perfect records but there's probably a clunker or a lacking somewhere to keep it from perfection. You won't feel bad about dropping some bones on these.
    3.5 Good - Most of the record is good, but there may be some filler. This is the OK range where you'd search for the record on sale or used.
    3 Average - Some good songs, some bad ones at about a half/half ratio. Could show skills but be dull overall. Redeeming qualities for indy bands are effort and passion. Majors that don't try or suck outright end up here.
    2-2.5 Fair - Worth a listen, but best obtained by collectors. There is much better metal out there.
    1-1.5 Bad - Major problems with music, lyrics, production, etc.
    0 Terrible or an otherwise waste of your life and time.

    Note: Reviews are graded from 0-5, anything higher or not showing is from our old style. Scores, however, do not reveal the important features. The written review that accompanies the ratings is the best source of information regarding the music on our site. Reviewing is opinionated, not a qualitative science, so scores are personal to the reviewer and could reflect anything from being technically brilliant to gloriously cheesy fun.

    Demos and independent releases get some slack since the bands are often spent broke supporting themselves and trying to improve. Major releases usually have big financial backing, so they may be judged by a heavier hand. All scores can be eventually adjusted up or down by comparison of subsequent releases by the same band. We attempt to keep biases out of reviews and be advocates of the consumer without the undo influence of any band, label, management, promoter, etc.

    The best way to determine how much you may like certain music is to listen to it yourself.



    ALL FULL REVIEWS FOR: ULI JON ROTH
    CD
    TITLE BAND
    DOR
    REVIEWER DATE
    Scorpions RevisitedUli Jon Roth
    2015
    Vinaya Saksena5/1/2015
    Under a Dark SkyUli Jon Roth
    2008
    Vinaya Saksena7/17/2009


    ALL SUMMARY REVIEWS FOR: ULI JON ROTH

    No Summary reviews currently exist for them.


    ALL INTERVIEWS FOR: ULI JON ROTH
    INTERVIEW BAND INTERVIEWER DATE
    Uli Jon RothUli Jon RothVinaya Saksena5/20/2015


    YOU MAY ALSO LIKE THESE HARD ROCK STYLED RELEASES:


    << back >>






    ERIC COMPTON PICKS
    Demonica
    Demonstrous
    Shakra
    Back On Track
    Warrant (Amer)
    Rockaholic
    Consfearacy
    Consfearacy
    Ammotrack
    Come Die With Us

    GREG WATSON PICKS
    Warbringer
    Waking Into Nightmares
    White Wizzard
    Over The Top
    My Own Grave
    Necrology
    Ghost
    Opus Eponymous
    Hyde Abbey
    Hall of Shame

    FRANK HILL PICKS
    Five Finger Death Punch
    The Way of the Fist
    Lemmy
    Lemmy DVD
    Gentlemens Pistols
    S/T
    Katrina Johansson
    Love, Surrender, Forgiveness
    Volbeat
    Rock The Rebel / Metal The Devil

    DAVID LOVELESS PICKS
    Deathspell Omega
    Veritas Diaboli…
    Ulcerate
    The Destroyers Of All
    Marduk
    Frontschwein
    Fen
    Winter
    Throne of Katarsis
    An Eternal Dark Horizon